I Lead a Life of Crime*

Whether you read the news or crime fiction, you soon see that anyone might commit a crime once. In real life, a person might kill once in the heat of the moment. A fictional example is Victor Hugo’s Jean Valjean, who steals food to feed his family. The majority of people, though, aren’t in the habit of committing crimes. So the question is, what makes a person live a life of crime (I’m deliberately excluding serial killers)? There are a few possible reasons, and crime fiction shows them.

One reason is perhaps the most obvious: money. For some people, their survival and livelihood depend on crime. For instance, one of the regular characters in Andrea Camilleri’s Salvo Montalbano’s series is Gegè Gullotta. He’s a small-time drug dealer and brothel manager who’s known Montalbano since they were in school together. His enterprises are woven into the area’s economy even though they’re technically illegal. In fact, they’re so much a part of the local underground economy that Montalbano knows it makes little sense to try to ‘clean up’ those activities. Instead, he’s forged an understanding with Gullotta. He and his team mostly look the other way when it comes to Gollutta’s activities. In return, Gullotta supplies Montalbano with information that helps in solving cases.

Sometimes, people truly don’t see any other way to survive than to be involved in illegal activity. For instance, in one plot thread of Mark Douglas-Home’s The Sea Detective, we meet Preeti and Basanti, two teenagers who belong to India’s Bedia group. They are both from desperately poor families, so it’s decided that they will enter the dhanda, India’s sex trade. It may be illegal, but for these families, it’s a way to keep starvation at bay, and the two girls are nervous, but proud to be helping their families. The plan is for them to send the money they earn to their families, and after a few years, return to their villages, marry, and settle down. They are taken to Scotland, but it’s soon clear that the people who are paying their families are abusive and worse. Basanti manages to escape and naturally goes looking for Preeti. Her search leads her to Caladh ‘Cal’ McGill, an Edinburgh Ph.D. student in oceanography. She’s hoping that he will help her find out what happened to her friend. The mystery turns out to be dangerous, and Basanti and Cal learn that some highly placed people don’t want the truth to come out.

We see that also in Jake Lamar’s Viper’s Dream. It’s 1926, and Clyde ‘Viper’ Morton moves to Harlem to make good as a jazz artist. He soon learns that he’s not at the same level of talent as the jazz heroes of the day, so he settles for a job at an acquaintance’s barber shop. He’s barely scraping by, but he quickly discovers there are other ways to make money. Marijuana, for instance, is almost openly sold, and the major dealers have arrangements with the police to keep their businesses going. Viper’s smart, ambitious, and energetic, and he begins to make a name and reputation for himself. As the years go by, we see how Viper is drawn into the darker side of Harlem, mostly because of the power and money it brings. One wonders what he might have done had he had the talent to become a jazz star.

The unknown narrator of Patricia Melo’s The Body Snatcher has moved from São Paulo to a small town near Brazil’s border with Bolivia. One day, he happens to witness a small plane crash. He rushes to the crash site to see if anyone’s in need of help, but by the time he gets there, the pilot is dead. The narrator notices a backpack and, on a whim, grabs it and leaves. Later, he discovers that the backpack is full of cocaine. That much cocaine will bring in a lot of money, so the narrator decides to sell it ‘just this once.’ The idea is that he and his girlfriend will have the money they’ve dreamed of to leave the small town and make a life for themselves. At first the plan works. But then, we learn that the cocaine belonged to a Bolivian drug lord who is not happy that his inventory was stolen. Now, the narrator gets pulled into much more crime than he’d thought.

Of course, money (even financial desperation) isn’t the only reason that a person might turn to serious crime – even murder. In some cases, it’s thrill-seeking. For others, it’s because friends and acquaintances are involved in crime. And then there are those who have a larger purpose. We may not agree with their choices, but we can understand their motivation. For instance, In Sophie Littlefield’s A Bad Day For Sorry, we are introduced to Stella Hardesty, who lives in the small town of Prosper, Missouri. Sophie is the owner of a sewing supply store, but she’s also famous for another reason. Women who have been abused know that they can count on Stella to even the score. As she says at the beginning of the book, she has never killed a man (except her husband, and that was because she was defending herself). But when an abuser is in her sights, Stella pays that man a very unpleasant first visit. The goal is to teach him a lesson he won’t forget. If she has to make a return call, things get even more unpleasant. Stella gets involved in a dangerous game of cat and mouse with a criminal gang when the husband and son of one of her ‘clients’ go missing. In this case, the fact is that Stella does commit crimes on a regular basis. But as she sees it, she’s saving abused women.

It’s one thing to commit a crime (even murder). Anyone might do that under the right circumstances. But to lead a life of crime? That’s different and it’s interesting to think about why people make that choice. What’s your view?

*NOTE: The title of this post is a line from AC/DC’s Dirty Deeds Done Dirt Cheap.