There Ain’t Much Work Out Here*

There are some towns (and districts in large cities) that seem to have been left behind. If you’ve driven through them, or ever lived in one, you know the signs. Dilapidated homes, lots of empty shops and ‘to let’ signs, and more than their share of pawn shops and payday loan places. They can be depressing, and most people who have the option don’t want to live in places like that. But they also have their own personalities and their own cultures. And in crime fiction, they can serve as interesting backdrops to a story.

Catherine O’Flynn’s What Was Lost is the story of Kate Meaney. Ten-year-old Kate is growing up in an economically depressed Midlands town. No-one has a lot of money, and there’s not a lot to do. Many of the local shops have had to close, and plenty of people live in council housing. When a new mall called Green Oaks opens, there’s talk that it will bring more jobs into town, but so far, there’s not a lot of prosperity. Kate isn’t too held back by this bleak situation, though. She wants more than anything else to be a detective, and she’s already started her own agency, Falcon Investigations. She spends a lot of time at the local mall, because she is sure there’ll be a lot of crime there that she can solve. Although Kate’s content with her life, her grandmother, Ivy, feels she’d be better off going away to school. So, she arranges for Kate to sit the entrance exams for Redspoon, an exclusive school. Kate goes off for the exams, but never returns. A major search gets underway, but there’s no sign of the girl, not even a body. Twenty years later, Kurt, who works security at the mall, starts to see some strange images on his cameras: a girl who’s about Kate’s age seems to be wandering the mall, especially at night. Lisa Palmer, who works at one of the mall stores, happens to meet Kurt one night, and the two form an awkward friendship. It turns out that Lisa is the younger sister of Adrian Palmer, who was blamed for Kate’s disappearance, and she remembers the girl. Between them, the two go back to the past, so to speak, and find out what happened to Kate.

Eoin Colfer’s Plugged takes place in fictional Cloisters, New Jersey. It’s a run-down sort of town with dirty, gritty bars, loan sharks, and worn-out housing – not exactly the sort of place that inspires tourism. Daniel McEvoy is an Irish ex-pat who now works as a bouncer at Slotz, a sleazy casino/nightclub. It’s hardly a Michelin star restaurant, but McEvoy’s content enough there. Then, one of his co-workers, Cornelia ‘Connie’ DeLyne, is found murdered. McEvoy is a ‘person of interest,’ because he had a sort of relationship with the victim. He knows he didn’t kill his friend, though, and he wants to clear his name. He also wants to find out who is responsible. So, he starts asking questions. He soon finds himself in the crosshairs of some very dangerous people. And that’s to say nothing of the police, who are not at all convinced that McEvoy is innocent.

Brad Parks’ Faces of the Gone also takes place in New Jersey, this time in Newark. Like most cities, Newark has some upmarket areas, but its reputation is very working-class and rough-and-tumble. There are dive bars, drug dealers, quick loan places (don’t ask questions), and poorly constructed housing. Carter Ross is a reporter for the Newark Eagle-Examiner, so he’s seen Newark’s ugly side. One day, his boss sends him to a local vacant lot, where four bodies have been found. The first theory about their deaths is that one of them held up a local bar, and that the owner had them killed as vengeance. That story doesn’t really hold up well, though, and Ross soon begins to believe that there’s more to the story than that. So, he looks more deeply into the story. He finds that a lot of people are not willing to talk to him, and that makes his job more difficult. But he slowly starts to put the pieces together. And that gets him into more danger than he imagined.

One of the settings for Val McDermid’s The Grave Tattoo is an impoverished council estate in a run-down section of London. Life there isn’t easy to begin with, and there are issues with drugs, gangs, and all sorts of crime. One of the residents is Jane Gresham, a post-doctorate scholar whose specialty is Wordsworth. She’s barely making ends meet, but doing the best she can, and hoping for the chance for a full-time, funded university position. Then, she hears about the possible existence of an unpublished Wordsworth manuscript. If this is true, it could make her career. So, she makes plans to track the manuscript down, with no idea of dangerous that will be. Jane has befriended thirteen-year-old Tenille, who’s grown up on the estate. In Tenille’s story, perceptions, and choices, we see the impact of living in a run-down sort of place. It’s hard on everyone, and particularly difficult for young people who have no direction. Without spoiling the story, I can say that Tenille plays an important role in what happens.

And then there’s Y.A. Erskine’s The Brotherhood. Sergeant John White of the Tasmania Police service is called to the scene of a home invasion. With him, he takes probationer Lucy Howard. Tragically, White is killed at the scene; and, as you can imagine, his colleagues are determined to catch the person responsible. The most likely suspect is the burglar, seventeen-year-old Darren Rowley, who lives in Glenorchy, an economically depressed suburb of Hobart. There are few jobs and fewer prospects, and many of the people who live in Glenorchy rely on government assistance. The police are ready to close the case, write Darren off as hopeless, and send him to prison as soon as possible. At the same time, though, they have to be perceived as being fair and transparent, and considering all possibilities. Glenorchy isn’t the main setting for the story, but the scenes that take place there show the sort of background Darren Rowley has, and they provide an interesting look at the perspectives people have of those who live in such places.

Places like Glenorchy, that have seen better days, are not easy places to live. They’re unsightly and they can be very dangerous. Certainly they don’t do much to buoy hope. Yet, they have their own personalities, and they can serve as effective backdrops for a crime novel. Which have stayed with you?


*NOTE: The title of this post is a line from Billy Joel’s No Man’s Land.


8 thoughts on “There Ain’t Much Work Out Here*

  1. Small towns like you describe definitely have their own personality and add depth to stories. It’s interesting to see how some towns like this have certain things in common and yet are so different at the same time. Enjoy seeing how different authors handle towns like this. Great topic, Margot. Thanks for sharing.


    1. Thanks, Mason. And you make a very well-taken point. Each of those run-down places does have a unique culture and personality. They do have some things in common, as you say, but at the same time, they have their own ‘selves.’ That’s part of what makes them interesting settings for crime novels.


  2. I quite enjoy a trip to the seamier side of urban life so long as it’s somewhere I don’t know. Whenever it’s Glasgow I get irritated that authors always seem to concentrate on the grimy run-down bits of the city and feel they should show us off a bit better to the world! I wonder if other people feel that way about their own town – Newark is another one that always seems to get a bad rap. Whereas London and New York tend to get to show off their glamorous bits as well as their shoddy bits.


    1. You’ve got an interesting point, FictionFan, about how cities are shown. I have to admit, I don’t read a lot of books that show the beautiful parts of Glasgow (Newark, either, for the matter of that ). I wonder why that is. The fact is, most cities have both beautiful and ugly parts. If I’m going to read about a city, it’s nice to get a chance to ‘see’ both sides, if that makes sense.

      Liked by 1 person

  3. Great topic, Margot. Another author who springs to mind is George Pelecanos – his crime novels do a great job of depicting life in the less affluent parts of Washington D.C. (both in the present day and in the past). And of course he was one of the main scriptwriters for THE WIRE (Baltimore). I really like his work.

    Thanks for the post – I haven’t yet read WHAT WAS LOST; now on the list!


    1. Thanks, Mrs. P.! And you’re right about Pelecanos (I haven’t read him just lately – I must get back to his work!). And it’s interesting about Washington. I can’t say I’m intimately familiar with it, but it does have some absolutely gorgeous (and very expensive) districts, and some places that are run-down and shoddy. Pelecanos writes about them very well. And as for What Was Lost, I thought it was an excellent novel. I hope that, if you read it, you’ll enjoy it.

      Liked by 1 person

  4. Margot, great post. I’ve just finished another Spencer Quinn,Chet and Bernie book – Thereby Hangs A Tail – that features an abandoned desert ghost town.
    Another real life example springs to mind regarding the book and recent film – Nomadland. The main character in the film hailed from a company town, Empire in Nevada that quickly died when the mine closed down. I’m sure I’ve read that Detroit suffered a similar decline with the death of some industries important to the economy. Maybe not as dramatic perhaps. Some mining communities in the UK have suffered similar setbacks since Thatcher’s War on the Miners in the 80s. They’re still trying to recover to this day.


    1. Thanks, Col – glad you enjoyed the post. I’m glad, too, that you mentioned Spencer Quinn’s writing. He’s talented, and is quite good at depicting places. I’ll look forward to your review of Thereby Hangs a Tail when you get to it.

      Thanks, too, for mentioning Nomadland. Mining towns, factory towns, and so on have suffered greatly when the companies (or resources) went or factories closed. I lived for a few years in a town where one of the major employers was an appliance factory. When that closed, everything changed. It’s the same, I’m sure, for the UK mining communities. I’ve read what happened to them in the ’80s, and I can see how they’re still struggling to come back.


What's your view?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s