I think we’d all agree that there are plenty of societal wrongs that need to be righted. So, we donate, or we volunteer for a cause, or we find some other way to pitch in. Some people are thoroughly devoted to a cause and work at it full time or nearly so. That activism can be dangerous, but even when it’s not, activists are often very passionate about their causes. And that trait can make them interesting characters. In crime fiction, activism can lead in a lot of different directions…
In Agatha Christie’s One, Two, Buckle My Shoe (AKA The Patriotic Murders and An Overdose of Death), we are introduced to Howard Raikes. He is an activist and, so many people think, a radical, who wants society to be completely changed and made more equitable. He’s involved with Jane Olivera, whose uncle, Alistair Blunt, is a rather conservative banking tycoon, who has a much more cautious approach to any change. Raikes has butted heads with Blunt and those like him before. One day, Blunt goes to his dentist, Henry Morley. Later that morning, Morley is found dead in his office. One appealing theory is that Blunt was the real target. As you can imagine, Raikes becomes a suspect when it’s found that he was actually at the office building on the morning of the murder. Hercule Poirot was also there, so he works with Chief Inspector Japp to find out who the killer is, and what the motive is.
Scott Young’s Murder in a Cold Climate is the first of his two novels featuring Matthew ‘Matteesie’ Kitologitak of the RCMP. The real action in the novel begins as he waits at the airport in Inuvik for a flight that will eventually take him to Ottawa, where he lives. The plane arrives and Matteesie boards, along with a few other people. One of those other people is First Nations activist Morton Cavendish, who’s on his way to Edmonton for emergency surgery. When the plane arrives at Fort Norman, a gunman forces his way aboard and shoots Cavendish, killing him instantly. Matteesie saw the whole thing, but he doesn’t know who the shooter is or what the motive is. So, he begins to investigate. One good possibility is that Cavendish was murdered by someone who opposes his activism. But that’s not the only possibility, so Matteesie has to look more deeply to find out who’s responsible.
At the beginning of Donna Leon’s Through a Glass Darkly, a group of activists is protesting the dumping of toxic waste into Venice’s water supply. They’ve targeted the city’s glass blowing factories, in particular, the factory of Giovanni de Cal. The leader of the activists is de Cal’s own son-in-law, Marco Ribetti. Naturally, de Cal is furious at the activism, and the police are called. They arrest Ribetti, among others. Ribetti contacts his friend, Ispettore Lorenzo Vianello, for help. Vianello and his boss, Commissario Guido Brunetti, arrange for Ribetti’s release. But that’s only the beginning of the story. Not long afterwards, Giovanni de Cal’s night watchman, Giorgio Tassini, is killed in what looks like a tragic accident. But was it? And if it was murder, might Ribetti or one of his fellow activists be responsible? Brunetti and Vianello have to peel away more than one layer to find out the truth.
In Gail Bowen’s Kaleidoscope, we meet Riel Delorme, a Regina-based Métis activist. He and his group, the Warriors, are strongly opposed to any development in the city, because they believe it will disenfranchise people who are already struggling. This brings Delorme right up against a development company that wants to operate in the area. When one of the company’s employees is killed, Delorme and his group fall under suspicion. It’s all especially hard for political scientist and professor Joanne Kilbourn Shreve, because her attorney husband Zack represents the company. To make matters more complicated, her daughter Mieka has become involved romantically with Delorme. The real solution is to find out who the killer is, so the family won’t be torn apart.
Geoffrey Robert’s The Alo Release features New Zealand environmental activist Jay Duggan, who’s been working with a Los Angeles-based environmentalist watchdog group called the Millbrook Foundation. Lately, the group’s been keeping a careful eye on a company called Vestco, which is planning to release a genetically modified seed that it claims will eliminate hunger. The Millbrook Foundation is suspicious, and wants to prevent the release of this seed, but they’ve not been successful, and the release is scheduled soon. In the meantime, Duggan has decided to retire and return to his home in New Zealand. He invites two Millbrook colleagues to join him for a visit, and they agree. They board their flight from Los Angeles and head to Auckland, not knowing that after the flight took off, Vestco employee Henry Beck was murdered. Duggan and his companions become suspects, and the subjects of an international search. Now, they have to avoid the police, try to stop the release of the seed, and find out who really killed Beck.
Activists don’t always get involved in cases of murder, but they can run into trouble. Still, they are passionate about their causes, and work to improve life. We may get annoyed with them at times, but we also benefit from what they do.
*NOTE: The title of this post is a line from Buffalo Springfield’s For What It’s Worth.
An interesting subject for a crime novel, one I’d not really given a lot of thought to, or read anything connected that I can think of. I like the sound of the The Alo Release, set in NZ.
LikeLike
The Alo Release is a fast-moving novel, Cath, with some interesting themes. And, yes, it’s got a strong New Zealand setting that adds a great deal to the story. If you read it, I hope you’ll enjoy it.
LikeLike
I’m pretty sure I’ve come across quite a few such examples in crime novels, but can’t think of any off the top of my head. Perhaps the work of Susie Steiner or Eva Dolan?
LikeLike
It’s interesting you mention Eva Dolan, Marina Sofia. Some of her novels, I think, do include activists. And she’s quite good at creating compelling characters. And Susie Steiner has certainly addressed issues like immigration (as has Dolan) and some of the other issues that concern activists.
LikeLiked by 1 person
It’s a versatile plot point for sure, as there are so many potential causes to root for, and so many different degrees of commitment. And nowadays people are becoming more polarised and extreme, so I’m sure this will continue to feature in crime fiction!
LikeLike
You’re so right about the number of causes out there, KBR. I’ve noticed, too, how people have become more extreme and more divided than ever. It’s sad, really. But as you say, it means that this theme is likely to continue to show up in crime fiction, perhaps even more frequently than it does already!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Margo, your recall is impressive. I had forgotten about the activists in the books mentioned by Gail Bowen and Scott Young. Joanne Kilbourn, in the series by Gail, is an activist in several of the books. What struck me is that, while she has ideals, Joanne is a practical activist seeking change based upon what is possible. Gail has advised me that in her personal life she believes in activism that is focused on being practical.
LikeLike
Thanks for the kind words. Thanks, too, for your thoughts about Joanne. I agree with you that she is a practical activist. Her goal is to make positive change based on what is really feasible. I’m not surprised that her creator feels the same way. It makes sense, too, to blend activism with practical plans for achieving goals. It’s a balance that I can see being successful.
LikeLike
Margot, sorry I did not spell your name correctly.
LikeLike
No worries, Bill – I knew whom you meant!
LikeLike
And what about Cap Marvell, trying to free animals from experimenting labs and ends up dating the policeman who arrested her? Dating Andy Dalziel – now that’s real punishment for a crime… 😉
LikeLike
Hahaha! Yes, indeed, FictionFan! That is a fantastic example, for which thank you. And yes, I think dating Dalziel is quite the sentence, isn’t it?
LikeLiked by 1 person
I am always interested when your posts include books by Canadian authors, Margot. I have read several books in the Joanne Kilbourn series but I am not as far along as Kaleidoscope. I look forward to reading that one. I have not read either of Scott Young’s mysteries, but I just got a Murder In A Cold Climate on Kindle, so maybe I can try that one some time in 2025.
LikeLike
Oh, I hope you’ll enjoy Murder in a Cold Climeate,, Tracy. It’s got a very strong sense of place and culture, and the mystery itself is very interesting. As for Gail Bowen’s work, I’m glad y ou’re reading the series; it’s a top Canadian series in my opinion.
LikeLike