Today, there is a wide variety of options for those who need mental health care. It may be a matter of therapy, medication, or something else, but many people with mental health needs can live successful lives. It wasn’t that long ago, though, that institutions were the only option for people who couldn’t be cared for at home. There are still psychiatric hospitals and psychiatric wards in ‘regular’ hospitals and in prisons. But institutions are no longer the only choice when someone has mental health problems. Places like that can be effective settings for crime novels and thrillers. They can have an eerie atmosphere, and some appalling things have happened there. So people’s imaginations can conjure up all sorts of scary images. That can make for a very effective background to a story.
In Agatha Christie’s Three Act Tragedy, Hercule Poirot attends a cocktail party hosted by famous actor Sir Charles Cartwright. During the party, another guest, the Reverend Stephen Babbington, suddenly collapses and dies of what turns out to be poison. Poirot is, of course, asked to investigate. He’s working on the case when there’s another death. This time, Sir Bartholomew Strange, who runs a psychiatric sanatorium, is killed. Like Babbington, he dies of poison. Since many of the same guests were at both parties, it seems that the two deaths are connected. Everything changes when one of Strange’s patients, Margaret de Rushbridger, dies after eating poisoned chocolates. Now, Poirot has to find out what connects the deaths, and who had a motive for the three murders.
One of the central characters in Thomas Harris’ The Silence of the Lambs is Dr. Hannibal Lecter. He’s confined to a hospital for the criminal insane for very good reasons. However, he could be useful in an ongoing FBI investigation. It seems that someone whom the FBI has dubbed ‘Buffalo Bill’ has been abducting and killing young women and removing their skin. The idea is that Lecter could help to build a profile of this person, so the FBI can catch whoever is responsible for the murders. FBI agent Clarice Starling is sent to interview Lecter in what’s supposed to be a straightforward question/answer setup. But it turns into much more as Lecter tries to manipulate the situation to his advantage. Throughout the novel, we get a sense of what this psychiatric institution is like, and that adds to the atmosphere.
Geraldine Evans’ Dead Before Morning introduces Detective Inspector (DI) Joe Rafferty, and Detective Sergeant (DS) Dafyd Llewellyn, In the novel, the two are called to the scene when the body of a young woman is found on the grounds of the Elmhurst Sanatorium. It’s an exclusive place owned and run by Anthony Melville-Briggs. As you can imagine, he wants the case solved as quickly and quietly as possible, and he does not want to involve the press more than is absolutely necessary. Rafferty and Llewellyn get to work and soon identify the victim as a sex worker called Linda Wilks. Now the question is, what would she have been doing on the grounds of the sanatorium? Was she a patient? Did she know a patient? Was she killed elsewhere and her body dumped? If so, why? There’s a lot to untangle, and the detectives have to cope with pressure from Melville-Briggs’ highly placed friends, as well as the difficulty of talking to anyone living at the sanatorium.
Dennis Lehane’s Shutter Island is set mostly at the Asheville Hospital for the Criminally Insane, which is located on Shutter Island, off Massachusetts’ Outer Harbor. US Marshal Teddy Daniels and his assistant, Chuck Aule have been sent to the island because one of the hospital’s very dangerous patients, Rachel Solano, has escaped. She is somewhere on the island, and Daniels and Aule must find and apprehend her before she causes any harm or somehow escapes the island. It’s a dangerous mission, and as the search is carried out, all sorts of dark, ugly things about the hospital come to light. The atmosphere of the story is impacted by the eerie hospital and some of the people in it.
There’s also Jeannette de Beauvoir’s Asylum. In it, we meet Martine LeDuc, who is director of public relations for the city of Montréal. As such, she’s responsible for cultivating a positive image for the city and finding ways to encourage business and tourism there. When a woman is murdered and her body displayed on a park bench, this creates a public relations problem that only gets worse when three other women are also murdered and their bodies displayed. The mayor’s office asks Martine to liaise with the police department. Her contact will be Lieutenant Julian Fletcher. Together, the two begin to look into the murders. The trail leads to the city’s past, and to some dark secrets that have been hidden for decades. I can say without spoiling the story that this isn’t the work of a mindless serial killer, and the story reveals some dreadful things the city would rather not have come to light.
Psychiatric hospitals and institutions used to be the only choice for people with mental health problems. They have a very sad history and can be very atmospheric, eerie places. There are some still in use; most others no longer are. But they still have stories to tell and can be effective settings for a crime novel.
*NOTE: The title of this post is line from Pink Floyd’s Brain Damage.
So interesting, Margot. We’ve moved on a lot since those days of locking people up with dreadful treatments – but that setting did make for some really interesting mysteries and the authors created some particularly memorable characters!
Thanks, KBR. You’re right that we’ve bid good riddance to the days when people with mental health needs were routinely put in institutions and subjected to awful treatment. But those atmospheres have been really effective for some crime fiction, and yes, lots of memorable characters!