I Can’t See Why People Disagree Each Time I Tell Them What I Know Is True*

Few important issues are one-sided. That’s why there’s often a great deal of debate about them, and why they can be the cause of a lot of controversy. That debate and controversy can add a layer of tension and suspense to a novel, and can contribute to character development, too. So it’s little wonder that authors weave that sort of issue into their work.

In Agatha Christie’s One, Two, Buckle My Shoe (AKA The Patriotic Murders and An Overdose of Death), for instance, Hercule Poirot investigates the murder of his dentist, Henry Morley. The murder turns out to be related to the death of one of Morley’s patients, and to the disappearance of another. The police explore several avenues, including Morley’s personal life, as well as his list of patients. And one of those patients is influential banker Alistair Blunt. His stable but conservative views have aroused the anger of more radical elements, and the question of what course England should take at this difficult time (the book was published in 1940) is not a simple one. That controversy isn’t the reason for the murders, but it’s woven through the story, and it adds to the tension.

Legal novels often address controversial issues that can end up being divisive. And the well-written ones don’t make light of just how complex those issues can be. For instance, the focus of John Grisham’s A Time to Kill is the brutal rape of ten-year-old Tonya Hailey. Her attackers, Billy Ray Cobb and James Louis ‘Pete’ Willard, are quickly caught and arrested. But Tonya’s father Carl Lee isn’t sure the family will get justice, since the defendants are white and the Hailey family is Black and this is small-town Clanton, Mississippi. That fear, plus his grief and devastation, drive Hailey to ambush Cobb and Willard when they’re on their way to the courthouse. He kills both of them and wounds a deputy, and now, he’s going to be on trial for murder. Hailey asks local lawyer Jake Brigance to defend him, and Brigance agrees. It’s a very controversial case, though. Everyone has sympathy for Hailey, but vigilantism cannot be allowed or condoned. The case tears at the fabric of the town, and Brigance soon finds himself caught in the middle of the debate.

Several of William Deverell’s novels featuring Vancouver lawyer Arthur Beauchamp address controversial topics. Trial of Passion, for instance, takes up the issue of what’s sometimes called ‘date rape.’ Beauchamp is recruited to defend a college professor who’s been accused of raping a student. The defendant admits after a time that the two had sex, but insists that it was consensual. His alleged victim admits that she was at the professor’s home at a private party, but says that she did not give her consent and that she was raped. It’s a divisive case, and Beauchamp isn’t popular with everyone, since he’s defending the professor. The truth of what happened comes out as a result of the trial, and it’s interesting to see how that sort of controversy plays out in court.

A number of C.J. Box’s Joe Pickett novels explore the very difficult questions around land use. Pickett is a Wyoming game warden whose job is to ensure that the laws regarding hunting, fishing, and so on are obeyed. More than once, he goes up against poachers and those who want to use the land illegally. But that doesn’t mean he’s blind to the complexity of land use. On the one hand, preserving the land and its wildlife is a high priority (and those are the laws that Pickett is sworn to uphold). On the other, local livelihoods depend on things like land development projects and tourism. There are strong feelings on both sides of this issue, and Box acknowledges that as he explores it.

One of the most difficult topics to take up is the issue of race and race relations. Most people will admit that racism exists and that it needs to be addressed (and not just with ‘lip service’). It’s a controversial topic that brings up all sorts of strong feelings. It’s a global issue, too, so it’s not surprising that it’s found its way into a lot of crime fiction. A few of Attica Locke’s novels (Black Water Rising, Pleasantville, and Bluebird, Bluebird) directly address racism by looking at the way it impacts the characters. Black Water Rising and Pleasantville feature Jay Porter, a Black Houston-based environmental law attorney who goes up against racism and classism as he goes after large, powerful companies that are determined to stay in control. Bluebird, Bluebird is the story of Black Texas Ranger Daren Matthews, who investigates two murders (of a Black man and a white woman) that threaten the fragile racial relations in the small town of Lark, Texas.

Dwayne Alexander Smith’s Forty Acres also explores the topic of race. When attorney Martin Grey is wooed by a group of wealthy and well-placed Black men, he’s flattered at first, and wants very much to be in their ‘in crowd.’ Then, he’s invited to a weekend of whitewater rafting with the other men. Before long, though, he finds that the group has another agenda entirely – their own way to address the deep scars and long history of racism in America. He’s faced with some very difficult choices, and whatever decision he makes will cost him dearly.

It’s not easy to explore a divisive topic without it becoming melodramatic or unrealistic. But very often, books are important vehicles for bringing those issues up and discussing them. When the story’s done well and the characters are at the forefront, a novel can be a very effective way to talk about difficult things.

*NOTE: The title of this post is a line from Marc Shaiman and Scott Wittman’s Run and Tell That!

8 thoughts on “I Can’t See Why People Disagree Each Time I Tell Them What I Know Is True*

  1. I think my retreat into vintage crime this year has partly been driven by the fact that I can cope with the problems raised in them while I’m actively burying my head in the sand about some of the contemporary issues in current crime fiction! When the world returns to normal I shall jump back on… 😉 Merry Christmas, Margot – I hope Santa brings you loads of books! 🎅


    1. Ha! I know what you mean, FictionFan! It’s a lot less stressful to read about those GA problems and controversies than to think about what’s going on now! Hopefully 2021 will be a better year for all of us. Thanks for the good wishes! Have a lovely Christmas – I hope your Feline Authority Department allows you some time off, and that you’ve got lots of good books to enjoy. 🎄

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Margot: You raise several excellent legal mysteries I have read. I would add The Boat People by Sharon Bala where the challenge of Sri Lankans arriving by boat in Canada and claiming refugee status must be resolved except there is a surprise ending.

    It is normally trite to say cases rarely proceed to court where the facts are clear. However, America has just seen 60 cases filed by Donald Trump or on his behalf and they have lost 59 of them. I have read several of them and can hardly believe they were brought to court. Were the stakes not so high it would be funny. Feel free to edit if you do not want the commentary.


    1. No worries, Bill. I’m glad for your commentary. Not being a lawyer, I’m not sophisticated in such matters, but I thought those cases shouldn’t have been brought to court, either, and not just based on politics. It’s good to have your view on the matter.

      You make a well-taken point, too, about the sorts of cases that actually do go on to court. If the facts are clear, I can see how a case wouldn’t make it to court, or at least would be less likely to do so. It’s the cases that are not so clear-cut that need to be hashed out in court. That’s what makes a good legal mystery, in my opinion. There isn’t a clear answer. Thanks for including The Boat People, too. It’s another excellent example of the sort of book I had in mind.


    1. I like her work, too, Col. She takes up some difficult topics, which is no mean feat. At the same time, she tells a very good story. It’s not easy to do both!


What's your view?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s