The Men From the Press Said ‘We Wish You Success”*

I think most of us would agree that we need journalists. They provide important information, they share stories we need to know about, and sometimes they risk their lives doing so. Any healthy society needs a free press. But our relationship with journalists can be complicated. Sometimes documents and other information need to be classified for security reasons. Sometimes police don’t want too much information about a case to be revealed, because they don’t want to alarm the public, or they don’t want to alert a criminal. And sometimes victims of a crime don’t want reporters prying into their lives as they grieve a loved one or cope with trauma. It’s a complex dynamic, and we see that in crime fiction

In some novels, reporters are portrayed in a negative light. For instance, in Agatha Christie’s After the Funeral, we meet the Abernethie family. Family patriarch Richard Abernethie has recently died, and the family gathers for the funeral. During the gathering, Abernethie’s younger sister, Cora Lansqenet, says that he was murdered. At first, everyone hushes her up, but the next day, she herself is killed. Family attorney Mr. Entwhistle visits Hercule Poirot and asks him to look into the deaths, and Poirot agrees. The press finds out about the deaths, and the family is pestered with reporters. It’s hard on everyone and doesn’t make solving the case any easier. There are other Christie stories, too, in which reporters are presented in a negative way.

The first of Ed McBain’s 87th Precinct series, Cop Hater, takes place during a sweltering summer. Two police officers are killed, and at first, it looks as though the killer is someone with a vendetta against police officers. But both victims were in plain clothes when they were killed, so Detective Steve Carella isn’t convinced that they’re up against a crazed serial killer. It’s a difficult case, and the press doesn’t help. In fact, a reporter called Savage does more harm than good. For one thing, he prints something that Carella said out of context, and that harms the case. Then, he tries to follow up a lead of his own (one that he hasn’t shared with the police) and ends up getting another officer wounded. Needless to say, the people of the 87th are not happy with what Savage has done. The case is solved, but it’s been made more complicated by this reporter’s actions.

William Deverell’s Trial of Passion introduces Vancouver attorney Arthur Beauchamp. He’s just retired to Garibaldi Island when his former colleagues ask him to return and help with a difficult case. Professor Jonathan O’Donnell, acting dean of law at the University of British Columbia, stands accused of rape. The complainant is a law student called Kimberly Martin. O’Donnell’s hired Beauchamp’s former law firm to defend him, but he’s not satisfied with the job they’ve done so far. So, Beauchamp is drawn into the case. At first, O’Donnell denies having any sexual relationship with Kimberly Martin. Finally, he admits to it, but claims it was consensual. Naturally, this is a scandalous sort of case that attracts all sorts of press attention, most of it unwelcome. The lurid details that are reported make it very hard for Beauchamp to defend his client.

Of course, there are plenty of crime novels in which journalists uncover the truth and end up solving cases. For example, in Brad Parks’ Faces of the Gone, we meet Newark, New Jersey reporter Carter Ross. One morning, he’s sent to an empty lot where four bodies have been discovered. At first, the theory is that one of the victims held up a local bar, and the bartender killed the perpetrator and his accomplices. But it’s not as simple as that. The police can’t get anyone to talk to them about what happened, so they aren’t making much headway in the case. Ross begins with information he gets from some of his police contacts. Then, he starts speaking with the victims’ family members and others who knew them. Little by little, he learns what the four victims had in common, and that puts him on the right trail.

Emma Flint’s Little Deaths is the story of Ruth Malone. It’s 1965 New York City, and Ruth is the single mother of two young children. She works as a cocktail waitress, which alone raises people’s eyebrows. She smokes, dates men, and dresses provocatively according to local standards. Because of her lifestyle, Ruth is an outsider. One tragic morning, Ruth wakes to find her children gone. After a search, their bodies are discovered, and what was a missing person case becomes a case of homicide. The police are prejudiced and assume that Ruth is the murderer. All they need is enough evidence. But not everyone is so quick to call Ruth guilty. A reporter called Peter Wonicke has been following the story, and he’s not convinced by the police account. He wants to get to know Ruth and find out what really happened. He looks more deeply into the case, and that leads to an important question: if Ruth didn’t kill her children, who did?

There are many other books and series that feature journalists. For example, the protagonist of Alison Gordon’s Kate Henry series is a sports reporter for the Toronto Planet. Her special interest is baseball, and she covers the Toronto Titans for the paper. Because she’s a sports reporter, Kate has access to players, managers, and others that the police don’t easily have. So she’s privy to information that they don’t always know. Because she understands sports, especially baseball, she also has a valuable perspective on the cases that come her way. Her professional relationship with the police can get a bit complicated, because they have their job to do, and Kate is, after all, a civilian. But both she and the police want to solve the crimes they encounter. Among other things, the series offers an interesting look at the way the press and the police interact.

Journalists are critical to the functioning of a healthy democracy. They are invaluable sources of information, and they hold those in power accountable. But our relationship with journalists isn’t always easy. And perspective plays an important role in how a journalist is portrayed, at least in crime fiction.

*NOTE: The title of this post is a line from the Beatles’ The Ballad of John and Yoko.


Leave a Reply